14998 – Thunar spin up sleeping HDD even if all partitions unmounted

Thunar spin up sleeping HDD even if all partitions unmounted

Status:

CLOSED: FIXED

Priority:
Medium

Severity:
minor

Product:
Thunar

Component:

General

Comments

Description al_info 2018-12-30 11:23:48 CET

Hi,

On my laptop I use :
 * a SSD for boot and all tasks
 * a HDD for storing big files

The HDD is spun down at startup and the corresponding filesystem is unmounted. I succeed in disabling all services making the HDD periodically wake up.

The only problem is that this HDD spins up when I launch thunar for the first time. If I close thunar, spin down the disk, then launch thunar again, the disk stays in sleep mode...

Is there a way to disable thunar first access to umounted partition ?

Comment 1 al_info 2018-12-30 11:25:59 CET

I found this thread without answer talking about the same issue :
https://forum.xfce.org/viewtopic.php?id=11270

Comment 2 Andre Miranda editbugs

2018-12-30 18:15:36 CET

Do you see this behavior with other file managers, e.g. Nautilus, Nemo?
I ask because they also use gvfs and because I can't reproduce, all my computers are SSD-only :/

Comment 3 al_info 2019-01-14 19:49:58 CET

Same problem with nautilus. HDD spins up when nautilus starts for the first time. Then if I force HDD sleeping and launch nautilus again, HDD stays in sleep mode.

I guess these files managers use a daemon which starts when the program is first launched and stays in the background when closed, making faster the next program launch ?

Thank you for your reply, sorry for the delay

Comment 4 Andre Miranda editbugs

2019-01-15 13:04:15 CET

The common factor is gvfs, both file managers use it. As for daemons, besides thunar running in background here I have 4 related to gvfs, any of them could be poking your HDD from time to time.

There is a 10 year old thread about a similar issue: https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/gvfs/issues/49
It would be very helpful if you could confirm which process is accessing the hard drive: https://unix.stackexchange.com/q/274136

Comment 5 al_info 2019-01-23 22:13:19 CET

sudo blktrace -d /dev/sda -o - | blkparse -i -
  8,0    3        1     0.000000000   779  I   N 0 [hdparm]
  8,0    3        2     0.000008540   779  D   N 0 [hdparm]
  8,0    0        1     0.510149800     0  C   N [0]
  8,0    1        1     0.510261390    18  I   N 0 [kworker/1:0]
  8,0    1        2     0.510267160    18  D   N 0 [kworker/1:0]
  8,0    1        3     0.510273812    18  C   N [0]
  8,0    0        2     9.388389656   806  I   R 512 [udisksd]
  8,0    0        3     9.388391210   806  D   R 512 [udisksd]
  8,0    0        4     9.389282701     0  C   R [0]
  8,0    0        5     9.389299825    13  I   N 0 [kworker/0:1]
  8,0    0        6     9.389300790    13  D   N 0 [kworker/0:1]
  8,0    0        7     9.389302081    13  C   N [0]
  8,0    1        4     9.401620671   813  Q FWS [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1        5     9.401623915   813  G FWS [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0        8     9.401806074     0  C  WS 0 [0]
  8,0    1        6     9.401855860   813  A  RA 2048 + 32 <- (8,1) 0
  8,0    1        7     9.401856228   813  Q  RA 2048 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1        8     9.401857212   813  G  RA 2048 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1        9     9.401858075   813  P   N [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       10     9.401858609   813  U   N [dumpe2fs] 1
  8,0    1       11     9.401858994   813  I  RA 2048 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       12     9.401860501   813  D  RA 2048 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0        9    10.603619973    13  I   N 0 [kworker/0:1]
  8,0    0       10    10.603629000    13  D   N 0 [kworker/0:1]
  8,0    0       11    10.603643871    13  C   N [0]
  8,0    0       12    11.169246919     0  C  RA 2048 + 32 [0]
  8,0    0       13    11.173240441   814  Q FWS [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       14    11.173242608   814  G FWS [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       15    11.191930532     0  C  WS 0 [0]
  8,0    0       16    11.192021562   814  A  RA 2048 + 32 <- (8,1) 0
  8,0    0       17    11.192023179   814  Q  RA 2048 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       18    11.192026947   814  G  RA 2048 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       19    11.192030370   814  P   N [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       20    11.192031893   814  U   N [dumpe2fs] 1
  8,0    0       21    11.192032921   814  I  RA 2048 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       22    11.192038013   814  D  RA 2048 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       23    11.192130578     0  C  RA 2048 + 32 [0]
  8,0    0       24    11.197028392   814  A  RA 2080 + 64 <- (8,1) 32
  8,0    0       25    11.197029871   814  Q  RA 2080 + 64 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       26    11.197033958   814  G  RA 2080 + 64 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       27    11.197037241   814  P   N [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       28    11.197038861   814  U   N [dumpe2fs] 1
  8,0    0       29    11.197039906   814  I  RA 2080 + 64 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       30    11.197045389   814  D  RA 2080 + 64 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       31    11.197076480   814  A  RA 2144 + 128 <- (8,1) 96
  8,0    0       32    11.197077144   814  Q  RA 2144 + 128 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       33    11.197078501   814  G  RA 2144 + 128 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       34    11.197079808   814  P   N [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       35    11.197080132   814  U   N [dumpe2fs] 1
  8,0    0       36    11.197080558   814  I  RA 2144 + 128 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       37    11.197082112   814  D  RA 2144 + 128 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       38    11.197222970     0  C  RA 2080 + 64 [0]
  8,0    0       39    11.197320160   814  C  RA 2144 + 128 [0]
  8,0    0       40    11.197327386   814  A  RA 2272 + 256 <- (8,1) 224
  8,0    0       41    11.197328471   814  Q  RA 2272 + 256 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       42    11.197331898   814  G  RA 2272 + 256 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       43    11.197333706   814  P   N [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       44    11.197334931   814  U   N [dumpe2fs] 1
  8,0    0       45    11.197335656   814  I  RA 2272 + 256 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       46    11.197338650   814  D  RA 2272 + 256 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       47    11.197403472   814  A  RA 2528 + 256 <- (8,1) 480
  8,0    0       48    11.197404025   814  Q  RA 2528 + 256 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       49    11.197406341   814  G  RA 2528 + 256 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       50    11.197408089   814  P   N [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       51    11.197408466   814  U   N [dumpe2fs] 1
  8,0    0       52    11.197408883   814  I  RA 2528 + 256 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       53    11.197411129   814  D  RA 2528 + 256 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       54    11.197683094     0  C  RA 2272 + 256 [0]
  8,0    0       55    11.197904224   814  C  RA 2528 + 256 [0]
  8,0    0       56    11.198597224   814  A  RA 10504 + 8 <- (8,1) 8456
  8,0    0       57    11.198598387   814  Q  RA 10504 + 8 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       58    11.198601555   814  G  RA 10504 + 8 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       59    11.198604557   814  P   N [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       60    11.198606100   814  U   N [dumpe2fs] 1
  8,0    0       61    11.198606934   814  I  RA 10504 + 8 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       62    11.198612641   814  D  RA 10504 + 8 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       63    11.207120919   501  C  RA 10504 + 8 [0]
  8,0    2        1    11.207272143   814  A  RA 973342712 + 8 <- (8,1) 973340664
  8,0    2        2    11.207275053   814  Q  RA 973342712 + 8 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    2        3    11.207279419   814  G  RA 973342712 + 8 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    2        4    11.207283354   814  P   N [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    2        5    11.207285411   814  U   N [dumpe2fs] 1
  8,0    2        6    11.207286579   814  I  RA 973342712 + 8 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    2        7    11.207293816   814  D  RA 973342712 + 8 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       64    11.226224526     0  C  RA 973342712 + 8 [0]
  8,0    2        8    11.226346920   814  A  RA 973342720 + 32 <- (8,1) 973340672
  8,0    2        9    11.226349377   814  Q  RA 973342720 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    2       10    11.226355437   814  G  RA 973342720 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    2       11    11.226359277   814  P   N [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    2       12    11.226361502   814  U   N [dumpe2fs] 1
  8,0    2       13    11.226363386   814  I  RA 973342720 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    2       14    11.226370666   814  D  RA 973342720 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       65    11.226532403     0  C  RA 973342720 + 32 [0]
  8,0    2       15    11.226691837   393  I   N 0 [kworker/2:3]
  8,0    2       16    11.226696537   393  D   N 0 [kworker/2:3]
  8,0    2       17    11.226702467   393  C   N [0]
  8,0    2       18    11.245153980   806  I   R 512 [udisksd]
  8,0    2       19    11.245158390   806  D   R 512 [udisksd]
  8,0    0       66    11.249326681     0  C   R [0]
  8,0    2       20    11.249463044   393  I   N 0 [kworker/2:3]
  8,0    2       21    11.249468510   393  D   N 0 [kworker/2:3]
  8,0    2       22    11.249476217   393  C   N [0]
  8,0    1       13    11.260874223   817  Q FWS [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       14    11.260877252   817  G FWS [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       67    11.261053392   501  C  WS 0 [0]
  8,0    1       15    11.261094798   817  A  RA 2048 + 32 <- (8,1) 0
  8,0    1       16    11.261096033   817  Q  RA 2048 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       17    11.261099737   817  G  RA 2048 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       18    11.261102409   817  P   N [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       19    11.261104733   817  U   N [dumpe2fs] 1
  8,0    1       20    11.261105869   817  I  RA 2048 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       21    11.261110301   817  D  RA 2048 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       68    11.277483724   501  C  RA 2048 + 32 [0]
  8,0    1       22    11.277540864   817  A  RA 2080 + 64 <- (8,1) 32
  8,0    1       23    11.277541585   817  Q  RA 2080 + 64 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       24    11.277543450   817  G  RA 2080 + 64 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       25    11.277545044   817  P   N [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       26    11.277545869   817  U   N [dumpe2fs] 1
  8,0    1       27    11.277546455   817  I  RA 2080 + 64 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       28    11.277549260   817  D  RA 2080 + 64 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       29    11.277580476   817  A  RA 2144 + 128 <- (8,1) 96
  8,0    1       30    11.277580975   817  Q  RA 2144 + 128 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       31    11.277582474   817  G  RA 2144 + 128 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       32    11.277583425   817  P   N [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       33    11.277583903   817  U   N [dumpe2fs] 1
  8,0    1       34    11.277584241   817  I  RA 2144 + 128 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       35    11.277586000   817  D  RA 2144 + 128 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       69    11.277740133   501  C  RA 2080 + 64 [0]
  8,0    1       36    11.277791364   817  A  RA 2272 + 256 <- (8,1) 224
  8,0    1       37    11.277791844   817  Q  RA 2272 + 256 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       38    11.277793723   817  G  RA 2272 + 256 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       39    11.277794836   817  P   N [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       40    11.277795534   817  U   N [dumpe2fs] 1
  8,0    1       41    11.277795928   817  I  RA 2272 + 256 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       42    11.277797917   817  D  RA 2272 + 256 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       70    11.278087877   501  C  RA 2144 + 128 [0]
  8,0    1       43    11.278170974   817  A  RA 2528 + 256 <- (8,1) 480
  8,0    1       44    11.278171481   817  Q  RA 2528 + 256 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       45    11.278173463   817  G  RA 2528 + 256 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       46    11.278174728   817  P   N [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       47    11.278175320   817  U   N [dumpe2fs] 1
  8,0    1       48    11.278175963   817  I  RA 2528 + 256 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       49    11.278177910   817  D  RA 2528 + 256 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       71    11.278877695   501  C  RA 2272 + 256 [0]
  8,0    1       50    11.279844184   817  A  RA 10504 + 8 <- (8,1) 8456
  8,0    1       51    11.279844788   817  Q  RA 10504 + 8 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       52    11.279846209   817  G  RA 10504 + 8 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       53    11.279847633   817  P   N [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       54    11.279848477   817  U   N [dumpe2fs] 1
  8,0    1       55    11.279849001   817  I  RA 10504 + 8 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       56    11.279851888   817  D  RA 10504 + 8 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       72    11.280863726   501  C  RA 2528 + 256 [0]
  8,0    0       73    11.290468170     0  C  RA 10504 + 8 [0]
  8,0    1       57    11.290551081   817  A  RA 973342712 + 8 <- (8,1) 973340664
  8,0    1       58    11.290552049   817  Q  RA 973342712 + 8 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       59    11.290553965   817  G  RA 973342712 + 8 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       60    11.290555815   817  P   N [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       61    11.290556840   817  U   N [dumpe2fs] 1
  8,0    1       62    11.290557557   817  I  RA 973342712 + 8 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       63    11.290561049   817  D  RA 973342712 + 8 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       74    11.309469872     0  C  RA 973342712 + 8 [0]
  8,0    1       64    11.309545690   817  A  RA 973342720 + 32 <- (8,1) 973340672
  8,0    1       65    11.309546634   817  Q  RA 973342720 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       66    11.309548863   817  G  RA 973342720 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       67    11.309550772   817  P   N [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       68    11.309551870   817  U   N [dumpe2fs] 1
  8,0    1       69    11.309552600   817  I  RA 973342720 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       70    11.309555961   817  D  RA 973342720 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       75    11.309699112     0  C  RA 973342720 + 32 [0]
  8,0    1       71    11.309798391    18  I   N 0 [kworker/1:0]
  8,0    1       72    11.309800667    18  D   N 0 [kworker/1:0]
  8,0    1       73    11.309803519    18  C   N [0]
  8,0    1       74    11.323193737   819  Q FWS [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       75    11.323196177   819  G FWS [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       76    11.331810480     0  C  WS 0 [0]
  8,0    1       76    11.331844017   819  A  RA 2048 + 32 <- (8,1) 0
  8,0    1       77    11.331845113   819  Q  RA 2048 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       78    11.331847930   819  G  RA 2048 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       79    11.331849859   819  P   N [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       80    11.331851272   819  U   N [dumpe2fs] 1
  8,0    1       81    11.331852154   819  I  RA 2048 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       82    11.331855219   819  D  RA 2048 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       77    11.331943145     0  C  RA 2048 + 32 [0]
  8,0    1       83    11.332029722   819  A  RA 2080 + 64 <- (8,1) 32
  8,0    1       84    11.332030374   819  Q  RA 2080 + 64 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       85    11.332032491   819  G  RA 2080 + 64 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       86    11.332034014   819  P   N [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       87    11.332034690   819  U   N [dumpe2fs] 1
  8,0    1       88    11.332035265   819  I  RA 2080 + 64 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       89    11.332037914   819  D  RA 2080 + 64 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       90    11.332068206   819  A  RA 2144 + 128 <- (8,1) 96
  8,0    1       91    11.332068658   819  Q  RA 2144 + 128 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       92    11.332070118   819  G  RA 2144 + 128 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       93    11.332070895   819  P   N [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       94    11.332071342   819  U   N [dumpe2fs] 1
  8,0    1       95    11.332071751   819  I  RA 2144 + 128 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       96    11.332073255   819  D  RA 2144 + 128 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       78    11.332164833     0  C  RA 2080 + 64 [0]
  8,0    1       97    11.332245305   819  A  RA 2272 + 256 <- (8,1) 224
  8,0    1       98    11.332245746   819  Q  RA 2272 + 256 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1       99    11.332248034   819  G  RA 2272 + 256 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1      100    11.332249082   819  P   N [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1      101    11.332249655   819  U   N [dumpe2fs] 1
  8,0    1      102    11.332250153   819  I  RA 2272 + 256 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1      103    11.332252332   819  D  RA 2272 + 256 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       79    11.332312511     0  C  RA 2144 + 128 [0]
  8,0    1      104    11.332427378   819  A  RA 2528 + 256 <- (8,1) 480
  8,0    1      105    11.332427885   819  Q  RA 2528 + 256 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1      106    11.332430405   819  G  RA 2528 + 256 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1      107    11.332431662   819  P   N [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1      108    11.332432238   819  U   N [dumpe2fs] 1
  8,0    1      109    11.332432741   819  I  RA 2528 + 256 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1      110    11.332434996   819  D  RA 2528 + 256 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       80    11.332617280     0  C  RA 2272 + 256 [0]
  8,0    0       81    11.332850080     0  C  RA 2528 + 256 [0]
  8,0    1      111    11.333833108   819  A  RA 10504 + 8 <- (8,1) 8456
  8,0    1      112    11.333834310   819  Q  RA 10504 + 8 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1      113    11.333836839   819  G  RA 10504 + 8 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1      114    11.333839416   819  P   N [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1      115    11.333840788   819  U   N [dumpe2fs] 1
  8,0    1      116    11.333841596   819  I  RA 10504 + 8 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1      117    11.333846321   819  D  RA 10504 + 8 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       82    11.333956001     0  C  RA 10504 + 8 [0]
  8,0    1      118    11.334033582   819  A  RA 973342712 + 8 <- (8,1) 973340664
  8,0    1      119    11.334034680   819  Q  RA 973342712 + 8 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1      120    11.334036888   819  G  RA 973342712 + 8 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1      121    11.334039055   819  P   N [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1      122    11.334040312   819  U   N [dumpe2fs] 1
  8,0    1      123    11.334041064   819  I  RA 973342712 + 8 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1      124    11.334045029   819  D  RA 973342712 + 8 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       83    11.334147936     0  C  RA 973342712 + 8 [0]
  8,0    1      125    11.334217332   819  A  RA 973342720 + 32 <- (8,1) 973340672
  8,0    1      126    11.334218479   819  Q  RA 973342720 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1      127    11.334221108   819  G  RA 973342720 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1      128    11.334223247   819  P   N [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1      129    11.334224488   819  U   N [dumpe2fs] 1
  8,0    1      130    11.334225242   819  I  RA 973342720 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    1      131    11.334229239   819  D  RA 973342720 + 32 [dumpe2fs]
  8,0    0       84    11.334316480     0  C  RA 973342720 + 32 [0]
  8,0    1      132    11.334399645    18  I   N 0 [kworker/1:0]
  8,0    1      133    11.334401843    18  D   N 0 [kworker/1:0]
  8,0    1      134    11.334404607    18  C   N [0]

$ top
...
  784 al        20   0    2388    756    692 S   0,0   0,0   0:00.00 sh            
  785 al        20   0  413804  46524  32612 S   0,0   0,6   0:01.17 thunar        
  789 al        20   0  240476   7740   6796 S   0,0   0,1   0:00.01 gvfsd         
  796 al        20   0   18468   5208   4680 S   0,0   0,1   0:00.00 xfconfd       
  803 al        20   0  283808   9912   8928 S   0,0   0,1   0:00.01 gvfs-udisks2-+
  824 al        20   0  238392   6088   5476 S   0,0   0,1   0:00.01 gvfs-mtp-volu+
  829 al        20   0  236588   6200   5576 S   0,0   0,1   0:00.00 gvfs-goa-volu+
  834 al        20   0  243044   9040   6176 S   0,0   0,1   0:00.01 gvfs-gphoto2-+
  839 al        20   0  319248   9524   6620 S   0,0   0,1   0:00.00 gvfs-afc-volu+
  845 al        20   0  164884   7624   5108 S   0,0   0,1   0:00.00 gvfsd-metadata
  848 al        20   0  314440   8144   7072 S   0,0   0,1   0:00.02 gvfsd-trash   
...

Hard to say which gvfs process is in cause, PID changes. There is the dumpe2fs indication...

Comment 6 al_info 2019-01-23 22:25:50 CET

Ok, I made the test more precisely. The process dumpe2fs is started at thunar startup, before all gvfs processes. It wakes up the HDD, then terminates and gives place to gvfs processes.

Comment 7 alexxcons editbugs

2019-01-24 21:41:29 CET

Did not find any occurence of this call in the thunar code. Possibly it is hidden after some gtk/gio method.

Thunar as well can run without gvfs. What happens if you uninstall gvfs, is dumpe2fs still executed on thunar launch ?

Comment 8 al_info 2019-01-25 14:34:47 CET

Good point ! Uninstalling gvfs resolve the problem, but without gvfs, i can't browse samba network shares.

Should I close this bug report and report it directly to gvfs team ?

Comment 9 alexxcons editbugs

2019-01-25 20:29:04 CET

Yes, think it makes sense to close this report and open a gvfs bug / ask e.g . in a gvfs forum.

Please feel free to reopen if thunar e.g. should use a differnt gvfs startup procedure.

Comment 10 al_info 2019-01-27 11:58:52 CET

Thank you !

Comments

Bug #14998

People

Version

Attachments

Additional information